The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) advises parents to not let children watch television until after the age of two. They recommend that children over two years of age should limit their television consumption to no more than one to two hours each day.
I figured since I seemed to have turned out okay, I would ask my family their opinions regarding television viewing. Until recently, this is one topic that we have never had an in depth discussion about.
My parents
When my father, Tom and mother, Denielle were raising me and my sister they never used the TV to stimulate or occupy us. We were constantly on the move and had no interest in it.
“I didn’t want to take a mobile and naturally active child and immobilize them by exposing them to video games or the television,” said Denielle.
In addition, she has never liked the zombie look in kid’s eyes when they are mesmerized and glued to the television.
Television rules were never enforced because it was never an issue for us. On Saturday mornings my sister and I would watch one hour of cartoons before doing our chores. Rather than using the TV as a reward for doing chores and homework, our reward was a sleepover or being able to play outside.
“Your dad and I didn’t feel the television was a healthy way to reward you,” she said.
My mother is not against TV, given the right content. She feels that TV has become more of an issue today with my 16-year-old sister because the content keeps getting worse.
Psychologist, Tim Abihider is a stepfather and father of two sons. He feels that it is impossible to keep all human beings away from every form of negative stimulus. One specific form of negative stimulus is violence. He believes children are very impressionable; therefore seeing something of a violent and disturbing nature affects them in the same way adults are affected.
“As human beings we’re geared toward emotion. To say that you see something that is violent in nature that doesn’t have an effect on you doesn’t seem human or normal,” said Dr. Abihider.
He said that when observing an infant you see the full gamut of emotion, such as joy and sadness. One moment they are screaming in joyful ecstasy and the next moment they are screaming in excruciating pain. This is why it is crucial to discern with each individual what kind of filter he or she has with emotion.
According to Dr. Abihider, one person can have very sensitive filters and when they see violence have an incredible reaction to it. Another person can see that same act of violence and their philosophy of life and experiences give them a different reaction to it, which makes this whole topic very complex.
“The variance of reaction can depend on a genetic predisposition, an environmental stimuli or experience, and under that environment it can be emotional experiences, including family experiences,” he said.
I asked him, “If you can’t keep a child from seeing forms of violence, to what degree do you protect a child from some forms of violence or the amount of violence, and how do you interact with the child about those various kinds of experiences?”
He said that parents have to make some kind of discernment to the degree of violence their child is involved in, which includes the violence they will view.
Dr. Abihider emphasizes that it is impossible for a legalistic uniform standard, since every child is different.
“As a parent I want to be sensitive to my child’s difference, act accordingly, shape them accordingly, and not give them a universal standard of what is considered to be violent,” he said.
One example of this is when two children are watching TV and see a cartoon character step on an ant. One child might be affected in a negative way and the other not at all.
The standard of violence in this situation would be that since each child can interpret it in a different way, you would address the child that was affected.
My in-laws
Allan, Resource Specialist (RSP) is a language arts and math special education teacher at Dartmouth Middle School. My father-in-law has raised three sons and now has three grandsons.
“One problem that I have seen in the classroom is that the junior high students do not know how to discern reality versus fiction in TV and movies,” said Allan.
Two years ago he had twin boys in his language arts class that had very limited social skills and were seeing a speech pathologist. All of their writing assignments were related to video games.
“Sadly, their parents did not see it as a significant problem since they were getting a “C” average in the class when they could be doing better,” he said.
Mary, Hemet Unified School District Nurse joined her husband, Allan by limiting and monitoring TV and video games, especially as their boys got older. Brent, Ryan, and Kurt were very active and preferred to play outside and read books rather than watch TV. When they did want to watch TV or play video games they had to ask permission.
“TV and video games were a reward for doing chores and homework, but it was not part of their daily lives,” said Mary.
While raising their three boys they belonged to Feature Films for Families, which allowed them to purchase quality family videos with morals and values.
Mary said that one of the biggest challenges of parenting is when younger children are exposed to the viewing preferences of the older children.
“You really have to monitor little eyes,” she said.
My sister
My sister, Teresa does not think her 15-month-old daughter, Memphis should be watching TV when she could be outside playing.
Fortunately, for Teresa and her husband the TV has not been an issue since Memphis is usually oblivious to it. When the television is on they play and interact with her, rather than sitting her in front of it.
“I want TV to be a reward for finishing homework or doing chores once she’s older. I don’t want her to be like kids today that veg out on the couch, playing video games and watching TV all day,” said Teresa.
Like the rest of my family, Teresa does not think that television is toxic as long as you apply good parenting skills and do not make it an important part of your daily life. Like many other things in life, moderation is key.
For more resources and information regarding this topic, check out the following web sites:
www.aap.org
www.drgreene.org
www.kidshealth.org
www.maketvwork.com
7 comments:
I love the pic of him with the remote - so cute!
I do have a couple of the "Praise Baby" DVDs that I'll pop on for my son (9 months) and he will watch everything for a few minutes. Then he's off playing again. He especially likes seeing other children on the videos, and laughs when the come on the screen. I try to interact with him - "Look an elephant, oh a kangaroo, look at that little girl," etc.
I do think as he gets older, I've had to limit my TV time - I used to watch a lot more during the day because he was pretty oblivious to it. Now that he'll watch it and seems to be paying attention, it stays off all day long.
I'm sure this is a question every parent thinks about, I know I have. I have a nine and four year old. The four year old watches tv in the morning while my nine year old is at school. I have found two great stations ( Etv and Nick Jr ) that are great for teaching little ones their ABC's, counting, learning how to share, and teamwork. But by the time my nine year old gets home at 2:45 and his homework is done, they are both outside till right before dinner. I am so blessed my boys would rather be outside then inside being a couch potato.
I agree with the comments posted about television. TV should be taken in small doses, and monitor. When I have my granddaughter, she loves to watch sign language videos. In fact, she now communicates with me by signing; this has encouraged me to learn signing. Overall, it has turn out to be a fun and educational experience.
Hi Amber,
that last blog about signing video was from "Me" Lola Finley@ulv
I grew up as a tv junkie and learned this from my mom. However, there have been times in life where I had no tv signal and enjoyed the freedom. So, from a personal perspective and from observation of my friend's kids, I agree, tv needs to be limited. Definately, tv should not be used to keep a child "busy", it should be managed like anything else that could be an addiction, and should be used as a tool for learning.
Keep up the good research!
I definately think that TV watching should be limited and of course monitored. It is so much healthier for children to be outside playing in the fresh air and exploring. Too many children park themself in front of the TV for entertainment or lack of imagination/movtivation and then when it is not available or taken away they dont know how to cope with the bordom. Also, I dont think video games are healthy and there has been studies proving an increase of seizure activity in children. Very concerning!! I love the pic of Ethan "outside" and in the dirt!!! So healthy!! Luv ya!! Aunt Denise
My Daughter is 16 months old, and has no interest in TV. I don't think at that age kids should be watching TV. I think it will just bring on bad habbits in the future. I'll be honest though, there have been times when I wish she would just sit and watch a half an hour episode of the Backyardagans, and she won't! But in the end, I'm so glad she has no interest. She LOVES to be outside and playing in the dirt! I think video games should never be aloud, there's nothing good about them. And I think TV when kids are older should definitely be monitered!
Post a Comment